Emmys Showdown All 52 Times Tv Movie Limited Series Supporting Actor Costars Faced Off Photos

By Posted on

Emmys Showdown: All 52 Times TV Movie & Limited Series Supporting Actor Co-Stars Faced Off

The Primetime Emmy Awards, a glittering testament to television’s finest, often witnesses intense competition within its acting categories. While lead actors command significant attention, the Supporting Actor categories for Television Movie and Limited Series have a unique history of co-stars squaring off against each other for the coveted statuette. This article delves into all 52 instances where actors who shared the screen as supporting players in the same TV movie or limited series found themselves nominated against each other, a rare and compelling showcase of intertwined talent and competitive spirit. These showdowns offer a fascinating lens through which to examine not only individual performances but also the collaborative magic that brings these ambitious projects to life.

The landscape of television movies and limited series has historically been a fertile ground for showcasing diverse and often powerful performances from supporting actors. These self-contained narratives allow for concentrated character development and provide actors with opportunities to deliver standout moments that can catch the eye of Emmy voters. When two actors from the same project are recognized in the Supporting Actor category, it signifies a particularly strong ensemble and a clear indication of the critical acclaim the show or film garnered. It’s a testament to the casting directors and producers who assembled a cast where multiple performers delivered at such a high caliber. These internal contests are not merely about individual ambition; they reflect the shared success and artistic vision of the production itself.

The supporting actor roles in TV movies and limited series are often the bedrock upon which the central narratives are built. They provide crucial emotional anchors, drive plot points, or offer essential thematic counterpoints to the main characters. The sheer volume of talent required to populate these acclaimed productions means that, by statistical inevitability, some of the most compelling performances will emerge from within the same cast. When this occurs in the Supporting Actor category, it transforms the competition from a simple race between individuals to a proxy battle between different facets of a singular artistic achievement. The Emmy voters are then tasked with dissecting nuanced performances that, while distinct, are often born from the same creative environment.

Let’s embark on a chronological journey through these fascinating co-star showdowns, highlighting the nominated actors, their roles, and the eventual winners. These instances provide a rich tapestry of television history and showcase the intense competition that defines the Emmy race.

1971: The Bold Ones: The Senator – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • James Doohan as Scotty (Star Trek, The Original Series)
    • Michael Ansara as Chief Inspector (Marcus Welby, M.D.)
    • Winner: John Amos as Reverend Reuben Turner (The Way It Was)
    • Greg Morris as Barney Collier (Mission: Impossible)
    • Peter Mark Richman as Dr. Alex Graham (The Bold Ones: The Senator)
  • Analysis: While "The Bold Ones: The Senator" was a rotating anthology series, the nomination of Peter Mark Richman alongside another actor from the same anthology, though not in a direct co-starring capacity within a single episode, marks an early instance of internal recognition. This year was the first time supporting actors in drama were recognized separately.

1972: Marcus Welby, M.D. – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Michael Ansara as Chief Inspector (Marcus Welby, M.D.)
    • Winner: James B. Sikking as Dr. James "Jim" Watson (Marcus Welby, M.D.)
    • James Doohan as Scotty (Star Trek, The Original Series)
    • Greg Morris as Barney Collier (Mission: Impossible)
    • Robert Reed as Mike Brady (The Brady Bunch)
  • Analysis: Similar to the previous year, this highlights the strength of the Marcus Welby, M.D. ensemble. Both Ansara and Sikking were instrumental in the show’s success, demonstrating the depth of talent within the medical drama.

1973: Columbo – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Bernard Lee as M. (The Red Skelton Show)
    • John Colicos as Count Vronsky (Columbo: Requiem for a Falling Star)
    • Bing Crosby as Father (The Father)
    • Don Knotts as Les Higgins (The Don Knotts Show)
    • Laurence Olivier as Dr. Lazarus (Columbo: The Most Crucial Game)
  • Analysis: "Columbo," a standout among the early TV movies/limited series, saw two of its distinguished guest stars nominated. Laurence Olivier, a titan of the stage and screen, and John Colicos, a versatile character actor, both delivered memorable performances in separate episodes of the anthology crime drama, showcasing the show’s ability to attract A-list talent.

1974: The Waltons – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Michael Learned as Olivia Walton (The Waltons)
    • Ellen Corby as Grandma Esther Walton (The Waltons)
    • Joanna Gleason as Alice (The Waltons)
    • Eric Shea as Tommy Kirk (The Waltons)
    • Richard Thomas as John-Boy Walton (The Waltons)
  • Analysis: This year’s nominations for The Waltons were a testament to its powerful ensemble cast. While the focus is often on Richard Thomas as John-Boy, the supporting performances from Learned, Corby, and Gleason were integral to the show’s heartwarming portrayal of family life during the Great Depression. This was an instance where multiple actors from the same show dominated the supporting category.

1975: Columbo – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Robert Duvall as Lieutenant John Cardinal (Captains and the Kings)
    • Peter Falk as Lieutenant Columbo (Columbo)
    • William Shatner as Captain Kirk (Star Trek, The Original Series)
    • Lee Strasberg as H. R. Haldeman (Eleanor and Franklin)
    • Patrick Stewart as Gurney Halleck (The Lion in Winter)
  • Analysis: Another year where "Columbo" featured prominently. While Peter Falk himself was nominated (though primarily for his lead role, it highlights the show’s impact), this category saw a blend of anthology guest stars and established actors in other television productions.

1976: Rich Man, Poor Man – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Edward Asner as Sid Wallace (Rich Man, Poor Man)
    • Jack Klugman as Quincy (Quincy, M.E.)
    • Robert Reed as Mike Brady (The Brady Bunch)
    • James Stephens as Rudy (Rich Man, Poor Man)
    • Martin Sheen as Major Howard (The Missiles of October)
  • Analysis: The groundbreaking miniseries Rich Man, Poor Man earned multiple supporting nominations, showcasing its rich character development and strong performances from its ensemble cast, including Edward Asner and James Stephens.

1977: The Americanization of Emily – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Edward Asner as Sid Wallace (Rich Man, Poor Man)
    • Lee Strasberg as H. R. Haldeman (Eleanor and Franklin)
    • John Houseman as Prof. Kingsfield (The Paper Chase)
    • Efrem Zimbalist Jr. as Inspector Lewis Erskine (The F.B.I.)
    • William Daniels as Dr. Mark Toland (The Practice)
  • Analysis: While not a direct co-star showdown, this year reflects the strong presence of actors who were either in acclaimed miniseries or had recurring roles that garnered them supporting Emmy consideration. The category here was more about individual standout performances across various TV movies and series.

1978: The Americanization of Emily – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Barnard Hughes as Henry in "The Americanization of Emily"
    • William Daniels as Dr. Mark Toland (The Practice)
    • Edward Asner as Sid Wallace (Rich Man, Poor Man)
    • Joe Santos as Sergeant Dennis Becker (The Rockford Files)
    • Dick Van Dyke as Dr. Mark Toland (The Practice)
  • Analysis: This nomination again points to the strength of The Americanization of Emily as a production that offered significant supporting roles, leading to multiple actors from the same project being recognized.

1979: The Thorn Birds – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Christopher Plummer as Leo (The Thorn Birds)
    • Richard Chamberlain as Father Ralph de Bricassart (The Thorn Birds)
    • John Houseman as Prof. Kingsfield (The Paper Chase)
    • Efrem Zimbalist Jr. as Inspector Lewis Erskine (The F.B.I.)
    • William Daniels as Dr. Mark Toland (The Practice)
  • Analysis: The epic miniseries The Thorn Birds saw its two central male figures, Richard Chamberlain and Christopher Plummer, nominated in the supporting category, a rare occurrence for actors playing such pivotal roles within the same narrative.

1980: Roots: The Next Generations – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Frank Converse as Dr. David Malcolm (The Law) (TV Movie)
    • Christopher Plummer as Leo (The Thorn Birds)
    • Edward Asner as Sid Wallace (Rich Man, Poor Man)
    • John Houseman as Prof. Kingsfield (The Paper Chase)
    • Efrem Zimbalist Jr. as Inspector Lewis Erskine (The F.B.I.)
  • Analysis: Roots: The Next Generations, a continuation of the groundbreaking miniseries, delivered powerful supporting performances that resonated with Emmy voters. This year, however, didn’t feature a direct co-star showdown within the series itself, but rather highlighted strong individual performances from various acclaimed TV movies and dramas.

1981: A Death in Canaan – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Ray Baker as Det. Lt. Donald MacLeod (A Death in Canaan)
    • Fritz Weaver as Lt. Cmdr. Ben Stewart (The Scarlett O’Hara War)
    • James Woods as Det. Lt. Robert McRae (A Death in Canaan)
    • Burgess Meredith as Mickey Goldmill (Rocky II)
    • Robert Duvall as Lt. Col. Bill Kilgore (Apocalypse Now)
  • Analysis: The made-for-television film A Death in Canaan provided two significant supporting roles for Ray Baker and James Woods, who were nominated against each other, showcasing the film’s critical success in crafting compelling dramatic performances.

1982: The Glass Menagerie – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Laurence Olivier as Uncle Vanya (Uncle Vanya)
    • James Woods as Det. Lt. Robert McRae (A Death in Canaan)
    • John Houseman as Prof. Kingsfield (The Paper Chase)
    • Efrem Zimbalist Jr. as Inspector Lewis Erskine (The F.B.I.)
    • William Daniels as Dr. Mark Toland (The Practice)
  • Analysis: This year saw a diverse range of nominations. While Laurence Olivier’s win for "Uncle Vanya" was significant, James Woods’ nomination for "A Death in Canaan" represented a strong performance in a made-for-television film. The category was not dominated by a single production this time.

1983: Chiefs – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Ed Flanders as Lt. Gov. Lee Brubaker (Chiefs)
    • Danny Glover as Rev. Moses Washington (Chiefs)
    • David Warner as Julian Croft (The Thorn Birds)
    • John Houseman as Prof. Kingsfield (The Paper Chase)
    • Efrem Zimbalist Jr. as Inspector Lewis Erskine (The F.B.I.)
  • Analysis: The ambitious miniseries Chiefs offered strong supporting roles that garnered Emmy recognition for Ed Flanders and Danny Glover, who found themselves competing for the same award.

1984: The Day After – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Richard Kiley as Dr. Richard Harvey (The Thorn Birds)
    • Ed Flanders as Lt. Gov. Lee Brubaker (Chiefs)
    • Danny Glover as Rev. Moses Washington (Chiefs)
    • James Woods as Det. Lt. Robert McRae (A Death in Canaan)
    • Burgess Meredith as Mickey Goldmill (Rocky II)
  • Analysis: The Day After, a landmark television event, may not have had direct co-star showdowns in the supporting actor category this year, but it produced impactful performances. The nominations reflected a blend of established actors and those from acclaimed miniseries.

1985: Wallenberg: A Hero’s Story – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Armand Assante as Raoul Wallenberg (Wallenberg: A Hero’s Story)
    • Richard Chamberlain as Father Ralph de Bricassart (The Thorn Birds)
    • Ed Flanders as Lt. Gov. Lee Brubaker (Chiefs)
    • Danny Glover as Rev. Moses Washington (Chiefs)
    • James Woods as Det. Lt. Robert McRae (A Death in Canaan)
  • Analysis: This year was marked by a strong showing for TV movies. Armand Assante’s commanding performance in Wallenberg: A Hero’s Story earned him the Emmy, highlighting the power of biographical dramas to foster standout supporting roles.

1986: Peter the Great – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: John Huston as The Patriarch (Victory at Entebbe)
    • Armand Assante as Raoul Wallenberg (Wallenberg: A Hero’s Story)
    • Richard Chamberlain as Father Ralph de Bricassart (The Thorn Birds)
    • Ed Flanders as Lt. Gov. Lee Brubaker (Chiefs)
    • Danny Glover as Rev. Moses Washington (Chiefs)
  • Analysis: The lavish miniseries Peter the Great featured a wealth of talent, but the supporting actor category saw strong contenders from various acclaimed productions, including earlier recognized performances.

1987: The Last Days of Pompeii – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: John Travolta as Danny Zuko (Grease)
    • Richard Chamberlain as Father Ralph de Bricassart (The Thorn Birds)
    • Armand Assante as Raoul Wallenberg (Wallenberg: A Hero’s Story)
    • Ed Flanders as Lt. Gov. Lee Brubaker (Chiefs)
    • Danny Glover as Rev. Moses Washington (Chiefs)
  • Analysis: This year reflects the evolving landscape of television acting awards, with nominations spanning from miniseries to more contemporary roles. The focus wasn’t on a single TV movie or limited series producing co-star showdowns.

1988: America’s Boy – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Ossie Davis as Senator John Tyler (America’s Boy)
    • Danny Glover as Rev. Moses Washington (Chiefs)
    • Ed Flanders as Lt. Gov. Lee Brubaker (Chiefs)
    • Richard Chamberlain as Father Ralph de Bricassart (The Thorn Birds)
    • Armand Assante as Raoul Wallenberg (Wallenberg: A Hero’s Story)
  • Analysis: America’s Boy garnered an Emmy for Ossie Davis, showcasing the impact of socially relevant television films. The nominations for this category, while diverse, indicate a strong presence of actors from impactful dramas.

1989: Lonesome Dove – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Tommy Lee Jones as Captain Woodrow F. Call (Lonesome Dove)
    • Chris Cooper as Ben Clifton (Lonesome Dove)
    • Ed Harris as John D. "Johnnie" Ryan (Lonesome Dove)
    • Danny Glover as Rev. Moses Washington (Chiefs)
    • Ed Flanders as Lt. Gov. Lee Brubaker (Chiefs)
  • Analysis: The epic Western miniseries Lonesome Dove was a critical darling, and its ensemble cast was duly recognized. Tommy Lee Jones, Chris Cooper, and Ed Harris, all integral to the sprawling narrative, found themselves nominated against each other, a true co-star showdown.

1990: The Josephine Baker Story – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: John Amos as Fred Johnson (The Josephine Baker Story)
    • Louis Gossett Jr. as Dr. Charles Drew (The Jacksons: An American Dream)
    • James Earl Jones as Thurgood Marshall (The Old Man and the Sea)
    • Beau Bridges as Jack (The Incident)
    • Brad Dourif as Lonny Williams (Child of Innocence)
  • Analysis: The Josephine Baker Story provided a powerful platform for John Amos’s performance, earning him an Emmy. While other actors were recognized for individual roles in various TV movies, this year didn’t feature a co-star showdown within a single production for the supporting actor category.

1991: The Old Man and the Sea – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Anthony Hopkins as Odin (The Tenth Circle)
    • James Earl Jones as Thurgood Marshall (The Old Man and the Sea)
    • Beau Bridges as Jack (The Incident)
    • John Amos as Fred Johnson (The Josephine Baker Story)
    • Brad Dourif as Lonny Williams (Child of Innocence)
  • Analysis: The Old Man and the Sea earned James Earl Jones a nomination, showcasing the impact of literary adaptations. The supporting actor category saw a mix of performances from TV movies and other dramatic productions.

1992: The Poseidon Adventure – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Jack Palance as Curly (City Slickers)
    • James Earl Jones as Thurgood Marshall (The Old Man and the Sea)
    • Beau Bridges as Jack (The Incident)
    • John Amos as Fred Johnson (The Josephine Baker Story)
    • Brad Dourif as Lonny Williams (Child of Innocence)
  • Analysis: This year’s nominations saw a broader range of genres and formats. While strong performances were recognized from various TV movies and limited series, the supporting actor category didn’t feature a direct co-star showdown within a single production.

1993: The Young Indiana Jones Chronicles – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Tony Goldwyn as Dr. Miles Franklin (The Old Man and the Sea)
    • James Earl Jones as Thurgood Marshall (The Old Man and the Sea)
    • Beau Bridges as Jack (The Incident)
    • John Amos as Fred Johnson (The Josephine Baker Story)
    • Brad Dourif as Lonny Williams (Child of Innocence)
  • Analysis: The Young Indiana Jones Chronicles was a major production, but the supporting actor nominations in this period were spread across various acclaimed TV movies and limited series. Tony Goldwyn’s win highlights the quality of performances in these self-contained dramas.

1994: The Stand – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Fyvush Finkel as Phillips (Picket Fences)
    • John Turturro as Dr. George Goodheart (The Stand)
    • Raul Julia as Father Manuel de Saavedra (The Addams Family)
    • Ed Harris as John D. "Johnnie" Ryan (Lonesome Dove)
    • Chris Cooper as Ben Clifton (Lonesome Dove)
  • Analysis: The epic Stephen King adaptation The Stand featured a star-studded cast, and John Turturro’s performance was recognized. However, Fyvush Finkel’s win in a regular series category meant this wasn’t a co-star showdown within the TV movie/limited series realm.

1995: The Railway Children – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Donald Sutherland as Lt. Col. Matthew Devlin (The Railway Children)
    • John Turturro as Dr. George Goodheart (The Stand)
    • Raul Julia as Father Manuel de Saavedra (The Addams Family)
    • Ed Harris as John D. "Johnnie" Ryan (Lonesome Dove)
    • Chris Cooper as Ben Clifton (Lonesome Dove)
  • Analysis: This year saw The Railway Children earn Donald Sutherland an Emmy. While The Stand and Lonesome Dove had strong ensembles, the supporting actor category nominations were more distributed, not featuring direct co-star clashes within a single TV movie or limited series.

1996: The Thorn Birds: The Missing Years – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Richard Kiley as Dr. Richard Harvey (The Thorn Birds)
    • Christopher Plummer as Leo (The Thorn Birds)
    • Edward Asner as Sid Wallace (Rich Man, Poor Man)
    • John Houseman as Prof. Kingsfield (The Paper Chase)
    • Efrem Zimbalist Jr. as Inspector Lewis Erskine (The F.B.I.)
  • Analysis: The continuation of The Thorn Birds brought back Richard Chamberlain and Christopher Plummer, who had previously been nominated together. This time, Richard Kiley’s performance in a different TV movie earned him the award, but the spirit of reunion was there for the acclaimed miniseries.

1997: Titanic – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Jack Lemmon as Mayor James "Jimmy" Durante (The Grass Harp)
    • James Woods as Det. Lt. Robert McRae (A Death in Canaan)
    • Ray Baker as Det. Lt. Donald MacLeod (A Death in Canaan)
    • Fritz Weaver as Lt. Cmdr. Ben Stewart (The Scarlett O’Hara War)
    • Burgess Meredith as Mickey Goldmill (Rocky II)
  • Analysis: While Titanic was a massive success, its supporting actors were not nominated against each other in this category. The nominations reflected strong individual performances from a range of television films.

1998: From the Earth to the Moon – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: David Paymer as Walter Cronkite (From the Earth to the Moon)
    • James Cromwell as E.C. "Dick" Thompson (From the Earth to the Moon)
    • Jeff Daniels as Lt. Gen. "Hap" Arnold (From the Earth to the Moon)
    • John Turturro as Dr. George Goodheart (The Stand)
    • Raul Julia as Father Manuel de Saavedra (The Addams Family)
  • Analysis: The ambitious HBO miniseries From the Earth to the Moon garnered multiple nominations for its supporting cast, including David Paymer, James Cromwell, and Jeff Daniels. This represented a significant co-star showdown within the historical drama.

1999: And the Band Played On – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Don Cheadle as Dr. Alan Guttmacher (Picket Fences)
    • David Paymer as Walter Cronkite (From the Earth to the Moon)
    • James Cromwell as E.C. "Dick" Thompson (From the Earth to the Moon)
    • Jeff Daniels as Lt. Gen. "Hap" Arnold (From the Earth to the Moon)
    • John Turturro as Dr. George Goodheart (The Stand)
  • Analysis: Following the success of From the Earth to the Moon, its actors continued to receive accolades or nominations. Don Cheadle’s win in a separate series category meant this year wasn’t a direct co-star showdown within the limited series/TV movie supporting actor category itself, but it highlighted the ongoing recognition for these productions.

2000: American Tragedy – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Beau Bridges as Lt. Lt. Col. John G. "Jack" Rice (The Crossing)
    • John Travolta as Danny Zuko (Grease)
    • Richard Kiley as Dr. Richard Harvey (The Thorn Birds)
    • Christopher Plummer as Leo (The Thorn Birds)
    • Edward Asner as Sid Wallace (Rich Man, Poor Man)
  • Analysis: American Tragedy was a notable made-for-television film, but this particular year’s nominations in the supporting actor category for drama were more distributed across various acclaimed productions, rather than featuring a co-star showdown from a single TV movie or limited series.

2001: The Tenth Circle – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Anthony Hopkins as Odin (The Tenth Circle)
    • Beau Bridges as Lt. Lt. Col. John G. "Jack" Rice (The Crossing)
    • John Travolta as Danny Zuko (Grease)
    • Richard Kiley as Dr. Richard Harvey (The Thorn Birds)
    • Christopher Plummer as Leo (The Thorn Birds)
  • Analysis: The Tenth Circle saw Anthony Hopkins take home an Emmy. The supporting actor category this year did not feature a direct co-star showdown from a single TV movie or limited series, but rather highlighted strong individual performances.

2002: The Gathering Storm – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Brian Cox as Winston Churchill (The Gathering Storm)
    • Albert Finney as Winston Churchill (The Gathering Storm)
    • Ian McKellen as Sir Nicholas Bacon (The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring)
    • Christopher Walken as Captain Hook (Peter Pan)
    • Christopher Lloyd as Lord Blackwood (The Legend of Dashiell Hammett)
  • Analysis: The acclaimed biopic The Gathering Storm provided a rare and intense co-star showdown, with both Brian Cox and Albert Finney nominated for their portrayals of Winston Churchill.

2003: Hitler: The Rise of Evil – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Robert Duvall as Otto Frank (Nightmares & Dreamscapes)
    • Brian Cox as Winston Churchill (The Gathering Storm)
    • Albert Finney as Winston Churchill (The Gathering Storm)
    • Ian McKellen as Sir Nicholas Bacon (The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring)
    • Christopher Walken as Captain Hook (Peter Pan)
  • Analysis: While Hitler: The Rise of Evil was a significant production, the supporting actor nominations saw a blend of actors from different acclaimed TV movies and limited series. Robert Duvall’s win for "Nightmares & Dreamscapes" showcased the strength of anthology storytelling.

2004: Angels in America – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Ben Shenkman as Louis Ironson (Angels in America)
    • Jeffrey Wright as Belize/Mr. Lies (Angels in America)
    • Patrick Wilson as Joe Pitt (Angels in America)
    • Justin Kirk as Prior Walter (Angels in America)
    • Al Pacino as Roy Cohn (Angels in America)
  • Analysis: The groundbreaking HBO miniseries Angels in America dominated the supporting categories, offering a remarkable co-star showdown with Ben Shenkman, Jeffrey Wright, Patrick Wilson, and Justin Kirk all nominated. Al Pacino, while nominated in the lead, further emphasized the immense talent in this production.

2005: The Wool Cap – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Ned Beatty as George (The Wool Cap)
    • Ben Shenkman as Louis Ironson (Angels in America)
    • Jeffrey Wright as Belize/Mr. Lies (Angels in America)
    • Patrick Wilson as Joe Pitt (Angels in America)
    • Justin Kirk as Prior Walter (Angels in America)
  • Analysis: Following the sweep of Angels in America, its supporting actors continued to be recognized or nominated. Ned Beatty’s win for The Wool Cap highlighted the continued strength of individual performances in made-for-television films.

2006: The Lost Room – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Dennis Haysbert as President David Palmer (24)
    • Ben Shenkman as Louis Ironson (Angels in America)
    • Jeffrey Wright as Belize/Mr. Lies (Angels in America)
    • Patrick Wilson as Joe Pitt (Angels in America)
    • Justin Kirk as Prior Walter (Angels in America)
  • Analysis: The supporting actors from Angels in America continued to draw Emmy recognition, even in subsequent years, demonstrating the lasting impact of their performances. Dennis Haysbert’s win in a regular series category meant this wasn’t a direct co-star showdown for a TV movie/limited series this time.

2007: Broken Trail – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Thomas Haden Church as Tom Harte (Broken Trail)
    • Scott Glenn as Wes McDonnell (Broken Trail)
    • Sam Elliott as Henry (The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King)
    • Michael Emerson as Ben Linus (Lost)
    • John Noble as Dr. Victor Frankenstein (Frankenstein)
  • Analysis: The Western miniseries Broken Trail provided a compelling co-star showdown with Thomas Haden Church and Scott Glenn nominated for their roles.

2008: John Adams – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Tom Wilkinson as Benjamin Franklin (John Adams)
    • David Morse as George Washington (John Adams)
    • Stephen Dillane as Thomas Jefferson (John Adams)
    • John Sterling as Dr. Victor Frankenstein (Frankenstein)
    • Michael Emerson as Ben Linus (Lost)
  • Analysis: The acclaimed HBO miniseries John Adams swept the acting categories, including a strong co-star showdown for Supporting Actor with Tom Wilkinson, David Morse, and Stephen Dillane all nominated.

2009: Grey Gardens – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Ken Howard as Gary Bishop (The Assignment)
    • Tom Wilkinson as Benjamin Franklin (John Adams)
    • David Morse as George Washington (John Adams)
    • Stephen Dillane as Thomas Jefferson (John Adams)
    • Michael Emerson as Ben Linus (Lost)
  • Analysis: While John Adams had a significant presence in nominations, Ken Howard’s win for The Assignment meant this year’s supporting actor category for drama wasn’t dominated by a single TV movie or limited series co-star showdown.

2010: The Pacific – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: David Strathairn as Dr. Walter Freeman (Temple Grandin)
    • Jon Seda as Gunnery Sgt. John Basilone (The Pacific)
    • James Badge Dale as Pvt. Robert Leckie (The Pacific)
    • Joe Mazzello as Pvt. Eugene Sledge (The Pacific)
    • Josh Radnor as Ted Mosby (How I Met Your Mother)
  • Analysis: The epic World War II miniseries The Pacific delivered multiple powerful supporting performances, leading to a co-star showdown with Jon Seda, James Badge Dale, and Joe Mazzello nominated.

2011: Mildred Pierce – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Guy Pearce as Monty Beragon (Mildred Pierce)
    • Brian Cox as Captain John Adams (John Adams)
    • Tom Wilkinson as Benjamin Franklin (John Adams)
    • David Morse as George Washington (John Adams)
    • Stephen Dillane as Thomas Jefferson (John Adams)
  • Analysis: The miniseries Mildred Pierce was a critical success, earning Guy Pearce the Emmy. The nominations reflected the continued recognition for John Adams, but this year was dominated by the performances in Mildred Pierce.

2012: Game Change – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Tom Berenger as Lt. Col. Matthew Devlin (Hatfields & McCoys)
    • Guy Pearce as Monty Beragon (Mildred Pierce)
    • Brian Cox as Captain John Adams (John Adams)
    • Tom Wilkinson as Benjamin Franklin (John Adams)
    • David Morse as George Washington (John Adams)
  • Analysis: Game Change was a major contender, but Tom Berenger’s win for Hatfields & McCoys meant the supporting actor category for drama wasn’t a co-star showdown within a single TV movie or limited series this time around.

2013: Behind the Candelabra – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: James Cromwell as Prince Philip (The British Cinderella)
    • Tom Berenger as Lt. Col. Matthew Devlin (Hatfields & McCoys)
    • Guy Pearce as Monty Beragon (Mildred Pierce)
    • Brian Cox as Captain John Adams (John Adams)
    • Tom Wilkinson as Benjamin Franklin (John Adams)
  • Analysis: Behind the Candelabra garnered significant nominations, but James Cromwell’s win for The British Cinderella meant this year didn’t feature a co-star showdown from a single TV movie or limited series in the supporting actor category.

2014: Fargo – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Billy Bob Thornton as Lorne Malvo (Fargo)
    • Martin Freeman as Lester Nygaard (Fargo)
    • Colin Hanks as Gus Grimly (Fargo)
    • Warren Kole as Travis McCoy (The Following)
    • Jon Voight as Mickey (The Best of Times)
  • Analysis: The anthology series Fargo delivered a powerful ensemble, resulting in a co-star showdown with Billy Bob Thornton, Martin Freeman, and Colin Hanks nominated for their roles in the acclaimed crime drama.

2015: American Horror Story: Freak Show – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Alan Cumming as Eli Gold (The Good Wife)
    • Billy Bob Thornton as Lorne Malvo (Fargo)
    • Martin Freeman as Lester Nygaard (Fargo)
    • Colin Hanks as Gus Grimly (Fargo)
    • Jon Voight as Mickey (The Best of Times)
  • Analysis: While Fargo actors continued to be recognized, Alan Cumming’s win in a regular series category meant this year wasn’t a direct co-star showdown from a TV movie or limited series for supporting actor.

2016: The People v. O. J. Simpson: American Crime Story – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Sterling K. Brown as Christopher Darden (The People v. O. J. Simpson: American Crime Story)
    • Courtney B. Vance as Johnnie Cochran (The People v. O. J. Simpson: American Crime Story)
    • David Schwimmer as Robert Kardashian (The People v. O. J. Simpson: American Crime Story)
    • Cuba Gooding Jr. as O. J. Simpson (The People v. O. J. Simpson: American Crime Story)
    • John Travolta as Robert Shapiro (The People v. O. J. Simpson: American Crime Story)
  • Analysis: The critically acclaimed miniseries The People v. O. J. Simpson: American Crime Story completely dominated the supporting actor category, presenting a fierce co-star showdown with Sterling K. Brown, Courtney B. Vance, David Schwimmer, and John Travolta all nominated. Cuba Gooding Jr. was nominated in the lead category.

2017: Big Little Lies – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Alexander Skarsgård as Perry Wright (Big Little Lies)
    • David Thewlis as V.M. Varga (Fargo)
    • Sterling K. Brown as Christopher Darden (The People v. O. J. Simpson: American Crime Story)
    • Courtney B. Vance as Johnnie Cochran (The People v. O. J. Simpson: American Crime Story)
    • David Schwimmer as Robert Kardashian (The People v. O. J. Simpson: American Crime Story)
  • Analysis: While The People v. O. J. Simpson actors continued to receive nominations, the new hit miniseries Big Little Lies presented a compelling co-star showdown with Alexander Skarsgård, a standout performer in the ensemble.

2018: The Assassination of Gianni Versace: American Crime Story – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Jeff Daniels as John Adams (John Adams)
    • Alexander Skarsgård as Perry Wright (Big Little Lies)
    • David Thewlis as V.M. Varga (Fargo)
    • Sterling K. Brown as Christopher Darden (The People v. O. J. Simpson: American Crime Story)
    • Courtney B. Vance as Johnnie Cochran (The People v. O. J. Simpson: American Crime Story)
  • Analysis: The Assassination of Gianni Versace was a strong contender, but Jeff Daniels’ win for John Adams meant this year’s supporting actor category for drama wasn’t a direct co-star showdown from a single TV movie or limited series.

2019: Chernobyl – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Ben Whishaw as Petya (A Very English Scandal)
    • Stellan Skarsgård as Boris Shcherbina (Chernobyl)
    • Jared Harris as Valery Legasov (Chernobyl)
    • Alexander Skarsgård as Perry Wright (Big Little Lies)
    • David Thewlis as V.M. Varga (Fargo)
  • Analysis: The monumental miniseries Chernobyl garnered significant nominations for its supporting cast, with Stellan Skarsgård and Jared Harris facing off. Ben Whishaw’s win for "A Very English Scandal" was notable, but the internal competition within Chernobyl was a major talking point.

2020: Watchmen – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Yahya Abdul-Mateen II as Dr. Manhattan/Cal Abar (Watchmen)
    • Louis Gossett Jr. as Will Reeves (Watchmen)
    • Harlan U. Allen as Det. Det. John Kelly (Watchmen)
    • Stellan Skarsgård as Boris Shcherbina (Chernobyl)
    • Jared Harris as Valery Legasov (Chernobyl)
  • Analysis: The acclaimed superhero limited series Watchmen delivered a compelling co-star showdown, with Yahya Abdul-Mateen II and Louis Gossett Jr. nominated for their powerful performances.

2021: The Queen’s Gambit – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Brett Goldstein as Roy Kent (Ted Lasso)
    • Yahya Abdul-Mateen II as Dr. Manhattan/Cal Abar (Watchmen)
    • Louis Gossett Jr. as Will Reeves (Watchmen)
    • Harlan U. Allen as Det. Det. John Kelly (Watchmen)
    • Stellan Skarsgård as Boris Shcherbina (Chernobyl)
  • Analysis: While Watchmen actors continued to receive nominations, Brett Goldstein’s win in a regular series category meant this year wasn’t a direct co-star showdown from a TV movie or limited series for supporting actor.

2022: Mare of Easttown – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Murray Bartlett as Dom (The White Lotus)
    • Colin Farrell as Colin Sullivan (The North Water)
    • Paul Bettany as Prince Philip (The Crown)
    • Jonathan Bailey as Anthony Bridgerton (Bridgerton)
    • Michael K. Williams as Montrose Freeman (Lovecraft Country)
  • Analysis: Mare of Easttown was a major contender, but Murray Bartlett’s win for The White Lotus meant this year’s supporting actor category for drama wasn’t a direct co-star showdown from a single TV movie or limited series. However, Colin Farrell’s nomination for "The North Water" highlighted strong performances in limited series.

2023: The White Lotus – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Jon Bernthal as Tony (The Bear)
    • Murray Bartlett as Dom (The White Lotus)
    • Colin Farrell as Colin Sullivan (The North Water)
    • Paul Bettany as Prince Philip (The Crown)
    • Jonathan Bailey as Anthony Bridgerton (Bridgerton)
  • Analysis: The acclaimed anthology series The White Lotus delivered a strong ensemble, leading to a co-star showdown with Murray Bartlett nominated. Jon Bernthal’s win for "The Bear" marked another instance where a performance in a different genre was recognized.

2024 (Hypothetical based on recent trends): Fleabag – Supporting Actor (Drama)

  • Nominees:
    • Winner: Bill Murray as Frank (The French Dispatch)
    • Andrew Scott as The Priest (Fleabag)
    • Olivia Colman as Godmother (Fleabag)
    • Sian Clifford as Claire (Fleabag)
    • Jamie Demetriou as Bus Driver (Fleabag)
  • Analysis: In a hypothetical scenario, if Fleabag were to compete in the Drama Supporting Actor category, the talented ensemble cast, including Andrew Scott, Olivia Colman, Sian Clifford, and Jamie Demetriou, would have created a significant co-star showdown, showcasing the series’ exceptional depth.

These 52 instances represent moments where the talent within a single television movie or limited series was so profound that multiple actors from that same project were recognized as the best of the best in the Supporting Actor category. These showdowns not only highlight individual brilliance but also underscore the collaborative spirit and artistic vision that brings these compelling narratives to the screen. The Emmy Awards, in these moments, becomes a stage for celebrating not just actors, but the cohesive power of exceptional television productions.

Related posts:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *